Skip to content

How Enoch.Wiki vets content

Enoch.Wiki holds itself to a public-authority standard. Nothing is presented as authoritative until it clears editorial review. Every public item displays its sources, perspective tags, claim-type label, and corroboration score.

Credibility tiers

Peer-Reviewed / Academic

Peer-reviewed journals, university presses, scholarly monographs.

Reputable Reference

Established encyclopedias, museum collections, reputable reference works (e.g. Brill, Oxford, Cambridge).

Popular / Journalistic

Reputable journalism and popular reference (e.g. Biblical Archaeology Society, Smithsonian).

Self-Published / Forum

Blogs, forums, YouTube, self-published books. Surfaced only with explicit flagging.

Perspective / tradition tags

Every claim is tagged with the traditions that hold it. A claim backed by one tradition reads very differently from one backed across many.

Apocryphal / Non-Canonical Text

Texts outside any mainstream canon (e.g. Gospel of Thomas, Apocalypse of Peter). Treated as historical witnesses, not scripture.

Catholic Tradition

Roman Catholic magisterium, Fathers, Doctors of the Church; Deuterocanonical canon.

Eastern Orthodox Tradition

Greek/Russian/Slavic Orthodox patristic tradition; Septuagint-based canon.

Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo

The 81-book canon; preserves 1 Enoch, Jubilees, Meqabyan, 4 Baruch as scripture. Ge'ez liturgical tradition.

Fringe / Speculative

Non-peer-reviewed theories: ancient aliens, Nephilim-as-ET, Christian Identity, occult interpretations. Surfaced only to flag and contextualize.

Jewish Sources

Hebrew Bible (Tanakh), Talmud, Midrash, rabbinic tradition. Second Temple period sources including DSS.

Mainstream Christian Scholarship

Christian academic theology across denominations; affirms faith commitments while using critical method.

Mystical / Visionary / Devotional

Private revelation and mystical theology: Anne Catherine Emmerich, Hildegard of Bingen, Julian of Norwich. Treated as devotional, not doctrinal.

Protestant Tradition

Reformation traditions; 66-book canon; generally reject Apocrypha as deutero-canonical.

Secular Academic / Critical Scholarship

Peer-reviewed historical-critical method; secular universities; skeptical of supernatural claims by method.

Claim type labels

Contested / Minority View

A real scholarly position but held by a minority; competing majority view exists.

Historically / Archaeologically Corroborated

Supported by external historical or archaeological evidence (e.g. Qumran fragments confirming 1 Enoch's antiquity).

Scholarly Consensus

Majority view in peer-reviewed academic literature (e.g. 1 Enoch composed 300-100 BCE).

Speculative

Extrapolation beyond what text or evidence supports; or fringe theory. Surfaced only with explicit flagging.

Textually Attested

The claim appears in a named text. Says nothing about historical truth — only that the text says it.

Tradition / Devotional

A claim held within a faith tradition without external corroboration (e.g. Enoch's assumption into Eden).

Visionary / Private Revelation

A claim originating in a private mystical vision (e.g. Emmerich's descriptions of Christ's descent into Hades). Treated as devotional, not factual.

Review rubric

Every item is reviewed against this rubric by a human editor before it can publish:

  • Sources cited and retrievable
  • Minimum credibility tier met (reputable-reference or higher for authoritative claims)
  • Claim type labeled
  • Perspectives represented (no single-source claims unless explicitly flagged)
  • No fabricated citations
  • Contested/sensitive claims flagged and contextualized
  • Authority not overstated

Content lifecycle

DraftAuto-CorroboratedIn Editorial ReviewApproved / PublishedRejectedNeeds RevisionArchived